Worst dirty martini ever. Sent it back. Brisket was like shoe leather and had zero flavor. Beans were liked canned. Mac and Cheese was marginal but was the best part of the meal, sadly. Is a one and done for us.
Overview
Located at 15 York St, Gettysburg, PA 17325, United States, Borough Bbq brings a barbecue-focused dining experience to a historic town known for its welcoming atmosphere and local character. This restaurant offers a setting where guests can enjoy the familiar comfort of smoked meats, hearty barbecue favorites, and a menu designed around satisfying flavors. Whether stopping by for a casual meal, a family gathering, or a flavorful lunch or dinner, the location provides a convenient spot for anyone looking to enjoy classic BBQ-style food in Gettysburg.
The appeal of Borough Bbq comes from the traditional approach to barbecue dining, where quality ingredients and careful preparation are central to the experience. Guests looking through the menu can expect a focus on the rich, smoky flavors that define American barbecue, with dishes that highlight the craft behind slow-cooked meats and comforting sides. The combination of savory selections and a relaxed atmosphere makes it a place suited for barbecue lovers who appreciate straightforward, well-prepared meals.
A great barbecue restaurant is often measured by the balance between flavor, texture, and portion satisfaction, and these elements help shape the overall dining experience. Smoked meats are a major part of what guests look for when choosing a BBQ destination, while side dishes and menu variety add another layer to the meal. The appeal extends beyond a single dish because barbecue is about the full experience, from the aroma of smoked flavors to the relaxed moments shared around the table.
The Gettysburg location also adds to the restaurantβs identity. Situated on York St, Borough Bbq is part of a community where visitors and locals come together, making it a practical choice for those exploring the area or searching for a dependable place to enjoy comfort food. Its location allows diners to include a satisfying barbecue meal as part of their time in town, whether they are visiting nearby attractions or simply looking for a neighborhood dining option.
Restaurant reviews often highlight the importance of atmosphere, service, and menu choices when deciding where to eat, and barbecue spots are especially connected to the feeling they create. A welcoming environment, flavorful food selections, and a menu centered around familiar favorites can make a meal feel memorable. Borough Bbq represents the kind of restaurant experience that focuses on bringing people together through generous portions, classic barbecue traditions, and a laid-back dining style.
For guests comparing different BBQ restaurants, important factors include menu variety, food quality, location, and the overall experience. A barbecue restaurant stands out when it creates a sense of comfort while delivering the flavors people expect from smoked and grilled dishes. Borough Bbq offers a destination for those seeking barbecue in Gettysburg, combining a convenient location with a menu style centered on satisfying, traditional favorites. Whether visiting for a quick meal or enjoying time with friends and family, this restaurant provides a place where barbecue remains the focus from the first bite to the last.
Good to know
Service options
β Outdoor seating β Onsite services β Takeout β Dine-in β No DeliveryHighlights
β Fast service β Serves local specialtyPopular for
β Lunch β Dinner β Solo diningAccessibility
β Wheelchair accessible parking lot β Wheelchair accessible restroomOfferings
β Alcohol β Beer β Cocktails β Coffee β Comfort food β Quick bite β Small plates β WineDining options
β Lunch β Dinner β Catering β Dessert β Seating β Table serviceAmenities
β Bar onsite β RestroomAtmosphere
β Casual β CozyCrowd
β TouristsPlanning
β Accepts reservationsPayments
β Credit cards β Debit cardsChildren
β Good for kidsParking
β Free street parking β Paid street parking β ParkingPhotos
Location
Reviews
The brisket was pretty good but feel it didnβt really have the Smokey flavor I was hoping for. The Brussel sprouts could have been cooked slightly less as well. Overall the food was good and itβs worth going back.
We enjoyed outdoor seating at Borough BBQ on a beautiful day. We had the gyro and cod and fries. Both meals were amazing and our drinks were refreshing. The staff were nice and the atmosphere was great, considering how busy they were.
The food is excellent. The sauces are great. The portions vs price wasnβt so great. The picture of the brisket was $18 for 6 slices. The ribs were $16 for 4 pieces. The pizza is a personal size and it was $19. The plates do not come with any sides for these prices. This small bowl of Mac n cheese was $7. They do have an EXTENSIVE list of alcohol they offer (but we arenβt drinkers). Overall, wonderful food. Just not enough. The parking wasnβt the best (but I do understand the location).
First time and it won't be my last. Delicious meats and sides and I need to try them all. Today I had the beef brisket sandwich, cornbread, onion rings,BBQ wings and fried green tomatoes. Sandwich, wings and cornbread was spot on. Very tasty. The tomatoes and onion rings were lacking flavor though still good and hot. Atmosphere is awesome and the waitress Sasha was great. Very attentive and helpful with questions. Went for a late lunch at 3pm and was the only ones there. Looks like a great place for a drink and pizza with Upper Crust right beside them. I would recommend this place to any meat lover.Update 9-22-23 Diner at 6pm and there was no wait. Server was amazing. Food was delicious and really good portions.
Lexie K. the bartender is amazing, personable, and friendly. Her drink, the key lime crush, is delicious, 10 out of 10. She is family oriented and we had a great time! Give that girl a raise!